Decision tool

Who Gets the Restock First? A Fair-Waitlist Decision Tool for Limited Units

200 people and 20 units: pick a rule you can defend, and tell people how you chose.

Two hundred people are waiting and you have twenty units. Whatever you do next, 180 of them will not get one, and how you choose is what they will remember. A rule you can defend and explain turns a disappointing restock into one that people accept. The tool below does two things: it shows how far your units stretch, then it compares five common rules, recommends the best fit for your priorities and writes the message you would send. If you want a waitlist priority restock fair to everyone, start here. The numbers shown are examples.

Step 1: How Far Do Your Units Go?

20
People who can buy
10%
Share of the waitlist served
180
People who will miss out
10
Waitlisters per unit
With these numbers, a rule matters: 180 people will not get a unit, so decide how you choose before you send anything.

Step 2: Pick Your Rule

Best fit

Choose your priorities above to see a recommendation.

Five ways to allocate a limited restock compared: first come first served, loyal customers first, staged waves, a per-person limit and an order-value cap, each with what it rewards
Each rule rewards something different. Choose the one you can explain in a sentence.

The Five Rules and Their Trade-Offs

First come, first served by signup order

The simplest to explain: whoever asked first gets the first chance. It works best when you can really notify people in signup order, and it fails quietly if everyone is emailed at once, because then it rewards inbox speed. Our limited restock waitlist guide explains that race.

Loyal customers first

Rewarding repeat buyers can be a fair choice if you say so. It costs you goodwill with newer shoppers, so announce the rule openly instead of applying it quietly.

Staged waves

Sending access in groups spreads checkout over time. It needs extra work, and the last wave may find nothing, so tell people that when you send.

A per-person limit

When demand is many times supply, a limit of one lets the most different people buy. Check that your terms and local rules allow you to cancel orders that exceed it before you rely on that.

An order-value cap

Capping the order value keeps one buyer from taking the batch, but it is clumsier than a limit per person and can feel arbitrary.

What Griffin Can and Cannot Control

Griffin, a Shopify back-in-stock app, adds a Notify Me popup or inline form to sold-out products, and shoppers sign up for the variant they want. For a limited restock, the app has a notification setting that caps how many restock emails go out per product, where zero means no cap. Emails beyond the cap are not sent for that restock, and Griffin also skips an email if its own stock record shows that variant out of stock again. Which subscribers fall inside the cap follows the order Griffin queues them, which is not a promise of signup order, so do not treat the cap as a fairness rule on its own. Confirm the setting's name and location in the app. Griffin does not offer staged waves, loyalty priority or purchase limits, so use your store setup or a manual process for those. The free plan includes 100 notifications a month.

When demand beats supply, a clear waitlist beats an inbox race. Griffin captures signups per variant and emails them when it is back.

Install Griffin on Shopify

Saying It Honestly

Whatever rule you choose, tell people. Say how many units exist, how you are deciding and what happens to those who miss out. Do not invent a countdown or a "last chance" you cannot back up; our honest low-stock messaging guide covers the line. For people who ask when more will come, the eight reply templates give you the wording, and the comparison of alerts and waitlists helps you choose the setup for the next drop.

FAQ

Who should get a limited restock first?

There is no single right answer. Pick the rule that matches what you value most, such as fairness to early signups, loyalty or reaching as many people as possible, then say openly which rule you used.

Is first come, first served the fairest rule?

It is the easiest to explain, and many shoppers see it as fair. It can still reward email speed instead of signup order if everyone is notified at once, so check how your tools send.

Can I limit how many units one customer can buy?

Often, yes, but how you enforce it depends on your store setup and your terms. Check the rules where you sell before you cancel any order for exceeding a limit.

What can Griffin control about a limited restock?

Griffin has a notification setting that caps how many restock emails go out per product, and it skips an email if its own stock record shows the variant out of stock again. It does not offer staged waves, loyalty priority or purchase limits.

The Bottom Line

With 200 people and 20 units, nobody can be fully satisfied, so aim for a rule that is honest, explainable and fair in the way you value most. Use the tool, choose one rule and tell your customers what it is. Griffin is a Shopify back-in-stock app you can install from the Shopify App Store, free to start.